One Of The Things Which Really Annoys Me About Dick Grayson’s Characterisation By Both DC And The Fandom

One of the things which really annoys me about Dick Grayson’s characterisation by both DC and the fandom is how they treat his being Romani (I say this as a gypsy from the circus myself) also before people cancel me for saying gypsy - I am not American and it’s not a slur where I am from. I am a gypsy myself so please don’t freak out about my using this term which feels comfortable and accurate to me

I know this is a common complaint, but being a gypsy or Romani is such a niche ethnic identity, and so often I see people treat it almost like a nationality. For example, the idea that Dick Grayson grew up not knowing English is so bizarre to me… of course he knew English, he may be Romani and speak it, but he is also American. The shopkeeper who he is buying food from doesn’t speak Romani, nor do the local authorities whose permission we need to even put on a circus/fair, so it makes sense that he’d speak English to them. He works in the circus: his family’s livelihood depended on his being able to draw a crowd - if he can’t interact with the people he’s taking the money from, how does he expect to make it in what is essentially a customer service job (I speak from experience here). Also, historically, by the late 18th century, the vast majority of Romani-speaking gypsies also spoke another language as a first language, and by the 20th century, I could argue that this is about 99.99999% of us, if not all.

The other thing I often see is how Dick Grayson is portrayed as being the Bristol-raised kid who doesn’t understand Jason’s Crime Alley upbringing. And yeah, whilst Dick lived with Bruce from a young age, and might (even based on his personality) have a better chance of mixing with the rich kids, let’s not act like Dick didn’t know struggle as a kid. Even if his parents were fairly comfortable economically, he spent at least half the year living in a trailer/vardo, which people associate with being working class. All gypsy kids are taught to fight from a very young age because whenever we pull on somewhere to open (aka put on the show), we expect a hell of a lot of racism from the locals, which often included getting jumped, often by multiple older gadja/gorja/non-gypsy children - and hell, even adults! As well as knowing how to defend ourselves, this also leads to a lot us developing a bit of a defence mechanism wherein we can talk ourselves out of a situation, or endear ourselves to people quickly in the first place so we don’t get fighting (keeping us safe, and keeping us in the good graces of the locals so we can continue earning a living there) - perhaps this could be explored as part of the reasoning behind the famous Dick Grayson charm? Anyway, all this to say, Dick would fully understand what it’s like to be the poor outsider who has to fight at every corner just to exist, and justifying his existence to others who view themselves as his ‘superiors’.

My final complaint is a small one: every single gypsy I know grows up absolutely BELTING Cher’s ‘Gypsies, Tramps, and Thieves’ and the fact that I’ve not seen Dick pouring his heart into that song, screaming the words ‘I was born in the wagon of a travelling show’ is honestly a hate crime which must be fixed immediately.

More Posts from Thornieta and Others

3 months ago
Some Rare Marwoods
Some Rare Marwoods
Some Rare Marwoods
Some Rare Marwoods
Some Rare Marwoods
Some Rare Marwoods

some rare marwoods


Tags
3 months ago

I got excited to read this then immediately discovered I alr have💀

New Fic Artwork To Be Used For My Castes Aruani Fic, A Nerd, A Punk And A PowerPoint Presentation!

New fic artwork to be used for my Castes Aruani fic, A Nerd, a Punk and a PowerPoint Presentation!

I wanted to make something striking to use for my chapter updates🩷 And well, it was also inspired by MANY teen movie poster references I've seen!

A massive thank you to everyone who has been reading my fic! It means a lot!

If you'd like to read it you can do so here!

Summary

When Armin is assigned a collaborative project with a mysterious delinquent, his high school life gets a lot more complicated. He never thought he'd become the protagonist of a teen flick.

3 months ago

Teenage Chisaki: You'd make a lovely lampshade. Teenage Kurono: Teenage Chisaki: That was supposed to stay in my head. Teenage Kurono: You worry me sometimes.


Tags
3 months ago
This Is What Happens When My Squid Game And Chronohaul Phases Overlap…

This is what happens when my Squid game and chronohaul phases overlap…


Tags
1 month ago

Rewatching Lost and I’m on s2 and I forgot how ominous the others seemed before their ‘official’ introduction?

Like it’s so laughably funny in retrospect that they were painted as these inhuman, incomprehensible collective entity. The tail-end survivors are under the impression they’re some kind of supernatural force, capable of moving through the jungle without leaving trace, and possessing a knowledge of the island’s layout that they can’t even dream of replicating.

I see a lot of complaints online that the show was better before the Others were revealed but honestly I love that, in a show full of bored gods and ancient temples, the Others were just people. People who’d grown with the jungle, adapted to tread lightly and move fast. People who spent their time bickering over book clubs and watching TV. I loved the later addition that the crash shook up their way of life almost as much as those on the plane; suddenly faced with a new group of people, unaware what that will entail for them.

In conclusion I really enjoyed the gradual portrayal of the Others within the show; their slow transition from omnipresent malevolent force, to a group of people thrust into a unique situation.

(I still firmly hold the belief that everyone was collectively winging it for a solid 90% of the first two season. I mean, there’s no indication that plane’s regularly crash; I can only assume that the last ‘surviving’ addition to the island was Rousseau. None of those mfs were at all prepared for 60+ people to suddenly appear. Props to Ben for coming up w a plan in the .5 seconds he had to register a PLANE CRASHING bcs that could not be me)


Tags
3 months ago
I Love Withnail And I. I Wish Gay People Were Real.

I love Withnail and I. I wish gay people were real.

3 months ago
The Gang When Buddy Holly Comes On At The Function

The gang when Buddy Holly comes on at the function

THANKS FOR THE INSPO @beanbagbog !!


Tags
3 months ago

sad rant time abt aot highschool caste au !!!

-

you know what destroys me when i think about it too much? aot high school caste au. ngl it cheers me up usually because its so damn funny.. but then i get sad when i think about the fact the caste version of the characters is what they could’ve and SHOULD’VE been if they weren’t forced into such devastating lives in the original canonverse. LIKE OKAY LISTEN… the fact goth mikasa is so whimsical and ditsy instead of the fierce and realistic canon au mikasa is basically isayama telling us that “haha mikasa could’ve had the chance to actually daydream like a normal teenage girl and explore her femininity lol” baby mikasa in the OVA’s was so innocent and airheaded, SHE COUD’VE CONTINUED BEING A NORMAL GIRLLL 😞😞😞 AND nerd armin in the caste au being so unaware of his surroundings and actually having the chance to indulge in living out his teen years in a life where he could focus on his interests.

-

bye im such a loser can someone else relate to my level of loser-ness for aot


Tags
  • handsomejackshairplugs
    handsomejackshairplugs liked this · 1 week ago
  • roguemagpie
    roguemagpie reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • roguemagpie
    roguemagpie liked this · 1 week ago
  • the-yellow-tumbllrine
    the-yellow-tumbllrine reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • who101
    who101 liked this · 1 week ago
  • vilevexedvixen
    vilevexedvixen liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • dariusblake
    dariusblake liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • littledragonlady
    littledragonlady liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • frenchlastname
    frenchlastname liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • missb0at
    missb0at reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • missb0at
    missb0at liked this · 2 weeks ago
  • dearestollie
    dearestollie liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • luitennentsunshine
    luitennentsunshine liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • 4oclockseve
    4oclockseve liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • marigoldandnasturtium
    marigoldandnasturtium liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • pedroezxe
    pedroezxe liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • whothere15
    whothere15 liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • moonlightdreamerh
    moonlightdreamerh reblogged this · 4 weeks ago
  • moonlightdreamerh
    moonlightdreamerh liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • turdinas
    turdinas liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • thisinhumanplace
    thisinhumanplace liked this · 4 weeks ago
  • twisted-pride
    twisted-pride liked this · 1 month ago
  • marysonla
    marysonla liked this · 1 month ago
  • purplish-pen
    purplish-pen reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • citriusly
    citriusly liked this · 1 month ago
  • cherrychewings
    cherrychewings liked this · 1 month ago
  • milquedraws
    milquedraws liked this · 1 month ago
  • prettypinkbubbless
    prettypinkbubbless liked this · 1 month ago
  • cocoasketch
    cocoasketch liked this · 1 month ago
  • grellsunofficalwife
    grellsunofficalwife liked this · 1 month ago
  • skyesayshi
    skyesayshi liked this · 1 month ago
  • oooowl
    oooowl liked this · 1 month ago
  • the-riddler-that-can-riddle
    the-riddler-that-can-riddle liked this · 1 month ago
  • vf22s
    vf22s liked this · 1 month ago
  • queen-of-wisdom
    queen-of-wisdom liked this · 1 month ago
  • aajeioo
    aajeioo liked this · 1 month ago
  • thatsaniceshirt
    thatsaniceshirt reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • nyoomuwuowo
    nyoomuwuowo liked this · 1 month ago
  • bat-anon
    bat-anon liked this · 1 month ago
  • cassie-cain-wayne
    cassie-cain-wayne liked this · 1 month ago
  • thatlovelydove
    thatlovelydove liked this · 2 months ago
  • kades-stuff
    kades-stuff liked this · 2 months ago
  • eiraeths
    eiraeths liked this · 2 months ago
  • ennix
    ennix liked this · 2 months ago
  • lea-ag
    lea-ag liked this · 2 months ago
  • pomilove33
    pomilove33 liked this · 2 months ago
  • yourgiiih
    yourgiiih liked this · 2 months ago
  • artsandbreakdowns
    artsandbreakdowns liked this · 2 months ago
  • depressedbisexualsblog
    depressedbisexualsblog liked this · 2 months ago
thornieta - Thornie
Thornie

Idk what I’m doing

89 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags